Tuesday 22 April 2014

Coping: Do you fake it until you make it?


In the eyes of my mother, being unable to cope was character condemnation of the worst kind. Throughout my 1950's and ‘60s childhood I became aware of people in our family's circle who just didn’t measure up.

Included in this blacklist were my father’s sister June and our immediate neighbour, Rita. Even as a child I perceived my aunt had a pretty awful life with an emotionally distant and errant husband who gave her little money, much less affection, beyond begetting by her six children. She was later diagnosed with a Bipolar disorder and one of my female cousins had the unenviable task of having to take steps to commit her own mother on more than one occasion.

The other woman was our neighbour, whose Portuguese descent manifested in her looks, vivacity and creativity. She was married to an austere Scotsman called Bill. They had one daughter, Margaret, a year or so younger than myself, who clearly did not take after her mother in looks. She was described in those days as being ‘a little slow’ although she attended the local school. We teased her mercilessly as children, something I feel ashamed of now. Somewhere along the line, Rita had had a nervous breakdown and in my mother’s eyes this was moral weakness. This triggered a diatribe of condemnation and judgement, along with a lack of compassion to which myself and my siblings had to bear involuntarily testimony.

Some years later I had a breakdown while my marriage was disintegrating. All my instincts, all the untruths and half-truths told me something was terribly wrong but my husband countered expressions of my concern by telling me I was hysterical and imagining things. This weary dialogue has been played out millions of times between men and their suspicious spouses. The link between being female and being hysterical are irrevocably conjoined by physiology and etymology in male psyches. In the midst of all my crying while trying to grasp a foothold in my newly disjointed world my mother told me in no uncertain terms to pull myself together. How dare I have a breakdown!  No one in our family had ever had mental illness, she told me. Ironically skeletons in the family closet manifest sooner or later and some years later I learnt of an uncle on my mother's side who had languished in a psychiatric hospital for decades, almost ignored by his immediate family who opted to have him kept there rather than ‘let out’.

All my adult life I have ‘coped’ and appeared to others as someone who can deal successfully with the vicissitudes of life. Just how you measure this success I never know. Is the benchmark of coping how others perceive you or the grim warts and all reality?

I have coped with being left with three young children to raise on my own, including a newborn. I had the support of my parents who bought me a car but I had little money and even fewer skills to equip me for the workforce. My coping mechanisms included, while being sleep deprived for months and being dangerously close to being bulimic, lining up at Social Welfare smartly dressed in order to deal with the whole degrading process of having to ask for money. Having an immaculate house and a stack of folded white, fluffy nappies demonstrated my coping skills when the *Plunket nurse called. This wasn’t just about housewifely pride though; the mechanics of household routine and the responsibility for three young children gave some structure to my life and there was some satisfaction to be found folding all those nappies into a nice neat stack.

I remember being so desperately tired, going through grief for both my marriage and my father, who died shortly after my baby's birth. I was dealing with my estranged husband, still seeking his approbation, which of course I never got. When I went to bed at night I truly hoped I wouldn’t wake up. Life was just too much to bear yet I managed somehow to put meals on the table, take the children to their after school activities and even go out and get a job when my youngest child was a couple of months old. To me a job meant I could shed the loaded tag of “Solo Mum”, (and subsequently any random male’s assumption that I was sexually available), and reinvent myself according to my job title. I kept up appearances. I had no truck with falling apart and languishing on a chaise lounge.

Overall I am proud of how I coped as a sole parent. I felt the fear, yet did it anyway; I faked it until I made it; I kept up appearances. Sadly, my mother never quite made it in this sense although she achieved a lot in her life. Losing her own mother at eighteen and later, her first child to meningitis at the age of two and a half years had a profound impact on the demeanour with which she would live the rest of her life. Neither of these situations were ones where you could fake it until you made it. As children, we just knew that conversation about our dead sister was taboo. I believe my mother ‘coped’ by channeling her grief and anger into tyrannical bouts of aggressive and irrational behaviour, (often focused on an individual), which continue to affect us all.

I am still single and wonder if my ‘keeping up appearances’ is the reason I have never met another partner I would truly love to spend the rest of my life with. As far as I know I never evoked from any man a fervent desire to protect and look after me. Did I ever allow any potential partner see my vulnerability? Probably not for I was hell bent on keeping up appearances of normality. Yet the paradox of this persona, the woman who could single-handedly do it all, was that for years Linda Ronstadt’s version of the torch song classic “Someone to Watch Over Me…” was a favourite. It encapsulated all the yearning for love, acceptance and intimacy I craved even while being supposedly ‘strong’. While I still crave those things, if I hear that song now and others of its ilk and era, I just think “How pathetic. Get a life. Pull yourself together, grow some.” Isn’t that what my mother was saying all those years ago?

Still I know my behaviour is unlikely to change. Few outside my own circle would guess that I am unemployed and between benefit payday and the following week there is little, if any, money in my purse. Would anyone ever guess the extent of my finances and that I have nothing to fall back on? I manage to dress well, have a good haircut and pay attention to my grooming. I present well and hopefully I am fooling the world. Likewise in job interviews, where my confidence and presentation have been favourably remarked on, though these are yet to get me a job. I have this internal struggle and dialogue with the self on a daily basis in order to rise above the endless drip, drip, drip of anxiety about my future. Anxiety and lack of motivation settles within me like a stagnant pool. It is a wearying process and it underpins your life while slowly eroding your vitality and confidence.

What still works for me in a very small but significant way, is when I am dressed, my hair and make-up done and I take a look at myself in the mirror. I CAN fool the world I tell myself, as long as I fool myself first, I can face anything. Go get ‘em girl! For to take some action, no matter how small, goes some way to prevent spilling over the edge into depression. Consequently I am still faking it, until I make it. I am busy keeping up appearances and hopefully eventual paid employment will do the rest.

*Child Health nurse

3 comments:

  1. Congratulations Isabel on an intimate piece that also resonates. It is easy for the reader to relate your experiences to other people’s behavious and also their own.

    I wondered how much of ‘keeping up appearances’ relates to culture and the middle class. Here in Bangladesh it is common for people to share intimate details, describe problems at length with strangers – on a bus, on the street... I recall a woman once narrating about her child who died (your childhood taboo subject) of diarrhoea because she didn’t know how to treat it, shortly after we met.

    It is not always like this and there are taboos here but it often seems as if those who speak openly – trouble conceiving, husband’s affair – are actually happier because they don’t carry the burden of their troubles with them. At a more basic level when people are sad they cry, when angry they let it fly. And the response in Bangladesh (despite what Bangladeshis might say) seems to be most often understanding and sympathy. There seems to be less gossip about other people’s problems behind their backs.

    Some reasons for this that I can imagine are, especially in the village, everyone knows everything anyway so there are no appearances to keep; there is a lack of centrality of ‘self’ to identity here so that difficulties are less attached or “blamed” on the person experiencing them – and part of that is religiousness which here manifests in terms of fate or destiny (again distancing the source of the problem from the self).

    But of course the western (middle class) context is rather more as you have so wonderfully described. And there can be merit, depending on the circumstances, in riding the storm rather than advertising it all about town! Not hoping to provide any answers here... just tapping into, penning down a few of the thoughts your piece gave rise to. I am sure many readers will gain from your thoughts. Well done!

    ReplyDelete
  2. Andrew thank you for your wonderful reply that gives much food for thought.

    When tragic things happen often our instinct is to 'spill' to anyone and talking to complete strangers is often easier because they have no emotional stake in the situation. While we have moved on despite campaigns to bring things like depression and mental illness into the open, people are still hesitant because those attitudes are still out there. I like the whole process of the Maori Tangi, though I have not experienced it, because you have the whole whanau of family sitting for some days besides the deceased, the service, the keening rather than a service at a funeral, cup of tea and a sandwich before going home and all is done. Mind you modern funerals in our society definitely for the middle class are now an upbeat celebration of that person's life which is how I think it should be.

    Your comment about gossip or lack of gossip in the village context is interesting. People probably more connected to their neighbours, everyone knows the others business, people share common struggles and triumphs.

    Thank you again.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Your confessions are so keenly insightful and poignant. Being able to cope. Wow. Our worth (self and how others view us) depend upon how well we can look after ourselves, as individuals. No, not team players at all. Instead, how the neighbors saw you was far more important than trying to help each other in a caring and loving way. I remember so clearly in my family of origin, being told that we don't "air our dirty laundry," meaning letting others see any flaws in our make-up as individuals or as a family unit. The facade had to be kept up, at any cost.

    Your descriptions of your working world as you were raising your children brings vivid memories of the not-too-distant past of working sometimes three jobs simultaneously, for six days a week for years and years. I only feel compassion and wanting to hug you when I think of all the tough times women like us have been through - in order to prove that we are not slackers or bad mothers. I, too, have never yearned to lay on the proverbial couch, eating bon bons all day. However, there is point where a helping hand, physically or financially, would be welcome. I guess that is the reason that marriage can be seen as a way out. But then, marriage becomes a solution to a problem instead of wanting to spend your life with someone who is loving and compatible. So, which is it? Wondering if "keeping up appearances" may be a reason for not finding a mate lies in this dichotomy. Wanting a relationship that is loving and kind means showing who we really are with all of the warts and the needs. Being able to be seen as functioning, and therefore datable, means putting on a front. Which is it then? The front (who is seen as together and functional) or the real person (who is seen as needy and flawed)? What a choice.

    You have really stirred the soup and gotten the bits that sink to the bottom (left alone for us not to see) brought up to the surface. There are more questions than answers, also.

    "For to take some action, no matter how small, goes some way to prevent spilling over the edge into depression." And this is the so meaningful and insightful a statement, I had to quote it.

    I love reading your blogs even though they stir the soup, emotionally.

    Thank you

    ReplyDelete